• Skip to main content
  • Skip to secondary menu
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
Addiction Treatment Forum

Addiction Treatment Forum

Addiction Treatment Forum reports on substance use news of interest to opioid treatment programs and patients in medication-assisted treatment.

  • Newsletter
  • Addiction Resources
  • Methadone
  • Buprenorphine
  • Patient Brochures
  • Events

Providers Oppose Allowing Law Enforcement Access to Patient Records

October 11, 2019 by Alison Knopf

Now that all the comments are in and counted, the votes are clearly against allowing law enforcement to have access to all patient records. The proposed change in 42 CFR Part 2, published by the Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration (SAMHSA) in the August 26 Federal Register, would allow the police to get all patient records, not just those of a patient alleged to have committed a serious crime, and would change the definition of serious crime to include anything related to drug trafficking.

Why Seek Care—or Remain in Care—If It Means Risking Criminal Charges?

The American Medical Association (AMA) put it bluntly: withdraw the proposal. If patients knew their medical information could go to law enforcement—even if they themselves were not accused of any wrongdoing—they would not seek treatment, the AMA said. This is the most compelling argument for OTPs: their patients who take methadone would risk so much if they lost confidentiality, but to risk criminal charges based on their medical record is a deterrent from seeking care.

In an opioid epidemic, in particular, deterring patients from seeking treatment makes no sense, something the AMA and the American Association for the Treatment of Opioid Dependence (AATOD) used as a central argument against this change in 42 CFR Part 2.

“Rogue Doctors,” “Pill Mills,” and “Fishing Expeditions”

The SAMHSA Notice of Proposed Rulemaking blames “rogue doctors” and “pill mills” for worsening the opioid epidemic. The AMA says there is no evidence proving this, and adds that the proposal sets the stage “for courts to authorize law enforcement access to a patient’s most intimate information without any criteria justifying such an invasion of privacy.”

As H. Westley Clark, MD, JD, dean’s executive professor of public health at Santa Clara University, California, said, these would be “fishing expeditions” in which patients’ records could all—not just those of a patient under suspicion of committing a crime—be scrutinized to see if there was any drug trafficking.

The proposal was also criticized by the Legal Action Center, AATOD, NAADAC, TCA, NAMA, Faces and Voices of Recovery, NAATP, and others. It should be noted that some groups that oppose allowing law enforcement access do support weakening 42 CFR Part 2, making it easier for health care providers to get access without patient consent.

The more general proposal, one which would most likely eliminate the current ban preventing opioid treatment programs (OTPs) from putting patient data in the Prescription Drug Monitoring Program (PDMP), was also published on August 26. It has a comment period ending October 25.

It’s important for OTPs and patients to comment on the second NPRM as well. The key change for them is the reporting of methadone information into the PDMP, without their consent.

For the two NPRMs (Notices of Proposed Rulemaking), go to
https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/FR-2019-08-26/pdf/2019-17816.pdf
and https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/FR-2019-08-26/pdf/2019-17817.pdf

Filed Under: 2019, 30-5, Newsletter

Primary Sidebar

Upcoming Events

CADCA 2023 Leadership Forum and SAMHSA’s Prevention Day
January 30-February 3, 2023

Washington, D.C.
http://cadca.org/forum2023

2023 Rx and Illicit Drug Summit
April 10-13, 2023

Atlanta, Georgia
https://www.rx-summit.com/

2023 ASAM conference
April 13-16, 2023

Washington, D.C.
https://annualconference.asam.org/

 

View More Upcoming Events…

ATForum.com

  • Newsletter
  • Addiction Resources
  • Rx Methadone & Safety
  • Patient Education Brochures
  • Events
  • Related Websites

Addiction Resources

  • Addiction and Recovery
  • Addiction Treatment Forum
  • Books and Booklets of Interest
  • Drug Screening and Testing
  • Evidence-Based Addiction Medicine
  • Federal Government
  • Health Care Reform
  • Hepatitis, HIV/AIDS
  • Medication-Assisted Treatment
  • Mental Health
  • Miscellaneous
  • Online Continuing Education Free Training Modules

Footer

Addiction Treatment Forum is produced by an independent medical communications agency. Commercial advertising is not accepted.
Published by Clinco Communications, Inc.
About Us
Contact Us
Privacy Policy
Terms of Use
Follow Us

Sign up for News!

© 2023 Addiction Treatment Forum · All Rights Reserved